TSDA General Session, 1999
TSDA General
Session
January 23, 1999
Convention Center
Fiesta D & E
San Antonio, TX
Program:
TSDA Featured Speaker: Gordon Hyde, M.D.
Management of Alcoholism and Drug Additon in Surgery Residents
and Faculty
Distribution and Introduction of the new Operational Guide
for Program Directors
Report for the Ad Hoc Committee on the Thoracic Surgery
Residency Match
Basic RRC
Information for TSDA Directors
TSDA Featured Speaker:
Gordon Hyde, M.D.
Management of Alcoholism and Drug Additon in Surgery Residents
and Faculty
Dr. Hyde, who has substantial personal experience with incidents of
abuse and rehabilitation, presented a lecture and a video that emphasized
the prevalence and impact of substance abuse among all physicians and specifically
among thoracic surgeons and residents. The video has been distributed
to Program Directors with the intent that the material will be shared with
residents and staff within individual programs.
Highlights:
-
The overachieving resident is prone to suicide by drug overdose.
-
60-80% of physician suicides are secondary to alcohol and/or drugs.
-
Particulars from a 1992 Survey of Residents were presented:
-
75% of residents admitted to excessive alcohol use within the previous
two weeks
-
24% of residents admitted to at least one use of cocaine (obtained from
a hospital)
-
Abuse and suicide rates are much higher for psychiatry residents than for
surgery residents, and the conclusion was that stress does not lead to
drug abuse.
-
Should drug testing be mandatory in residency? (comments offered)
-
What to do when abuse is discovered or suspected:
-
Confront the individual
-
Immediately invoke the process of the hospitals impaired physician committee
-
Immediately invoke the process of the states impaired physician committee
-
If help is refused, then suspend the individual
-
If help is accepted, then offer treatment program and re-evaluate
-
A potentially important resource is the American Society of Addiction Medicine
Stress Management
-
Stress is real and multifactorial
-
Symptoms include deterioration of interpersonal relationships, geographic
changes (new people and friends, multiple moves to different locations),
and deterioration of clinical skills.
-
22% of categorical surgery residents change specialties compared to 1%
of OB-Gyn residents
-
Burnout Syndrome written about by Skip Campbell at the University of
Michigan, who offers a day-long management course at $50.00 per resident.
Issues discussed include time management, stamina, relationships, and spirituality.
New TSDA Operational Guide for Program Directors
The first Operational Guide for Program Directors was developed and
distributed in 1994 by Dr. Gordon Murray, who was TSDA President at the
time. A variety of changes which have occurred since then (new bylaws,
new committee structure, nearly 30% turnover of new Program Directors,
etc.) have justified an update of the Guide. Dr. Mark Orringer and his
staff prepared a new Operational Guide for Program Directors which was
distributed and discussed at the San Antonio meeting. The Guide will serve
as a reference source for Directors regarding important TSDA, RRC and ABIS
rules, guidelines, forms, etc.
Ad Hoc Committee on the Thoracic Surgery Match
(Bartley Griffith, John Calhoun)
Questions and topics included:
-
Can we improve? (General discussion of ERAS [Electronic Residency
Application System])
-
Is the NRMP office adequate? (Yes)
-
Timing of the Match (Currently better, and perhaps optimal)
-
Cost of interviews (mixed considerations and suggestions, including:
preliminary screenings at STS or AATS meetings; set interview dates by
geographic regions; limiting the number of interviews granted by individual
programs; providing deadlines for interviews)
-
Input from Residents
-
Violators of the Match (increasing compliance by education of Directors,
letter of censure)
What is ERAS?
(taken with permission from Program Directors Workstation Instruction
Manual ERAS 99)
ERAS consists of four components: the Student Workstation (SWS),
the Deans Office Workstation (DWS), the Program Directors Workstation
(PDWS) and the ERAS PostOffice (ERASPO). Using ERAS Student Workstation
software, an applicant completes a common application and selects residency
programs to receive their application on a Student Workstation Data Diskette.
That diskette is then delivered to student affairs, academic affairs, or
other designated deans office. At the deans office, the completed
electronic application is uploaded on the Deans Office Workstation and
joined with the students Deans Letter, transcript, and faculty letter
of recommendation in an electronic file folder. Software at the Deans
Office Workstation then encrypts the files for security and transmits them
to the ERAS PostOffice over the Internet using ftp (file transfer protocol).
The programs designated by students download application materials
using their Program Directors Workstation, decrypt the files, and have
the option to review, sort, or print the application data using criteria
established by the program. There is no direct connection between
schools and programs. All transmissions are sent to and received
from the ERAS PostOffice.
The National Board of Medical Examiners (NBME) contacts the ERAS PostOffice
to download requests from the U.S. and Canadian applicants for USMLE/NBME
transcripts and forwards the USMLE transcripts to the ERASPO for downloading
by programs designated by the applicants. The Educational Commission
for Foreign Medical Graduates (ECFMG) acts as the designated deans office
for students and graduates of foreign medical schools and processes USMLE
requests for these applicants. ECFMG also provides an ECFMG certification
status report for all international applicants.
Further information is available from the AAMC
website and from its ERAS
pages.
Residency
Review Committee Information for TSDA Directors (John Brown)
RRC Status Determinations:
-
Provisional accreditation
-
Continued full accreditation
-
Proposed probation (6 month grace period for rebuttal)
-
Probation (Program Director obligated to notify current and future residents;
there is a 4 year limit with a requirement for repeat visit in 2 years;
this decision can be appealed to the ACGME)
-
Withdrawal of accreditation (this decision can be appealed to the ACGME)
The RRC requires immediate information regarding:
-
Change in Program Directors
-
Change in Department Chair
-
Change in hospital affiliation, mergers, deletions of affiliated hospitals
-
Unscheduled termination of a resident
-
Delay in completion of a residents education
-
Any rotation greater than or equal to 4 months at a non-accredited hospital
requires RRC approval